Based on my collection so far.
A list of the souvenir brochures

The goal of this section is to someday have photos of each brochure along with the cast lists. It'll never be complete, by any means but I sure can try.
Note: If there is a city, state and theatre listed, I either was at these performances, the name of the theatre was on the front of the brochure, or when I bought the brochure off ebay I had the info given to me by the seller.

The Majestic Theatre, Broadway, New York, NY

Images coming along with links	Year	Cast
	January 1988 - Autographed MC, Sarah B., Steve B., Judy Kaye	The Phantom - Michael Crawford Christine Daaé - Sarah Brightman Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman M. André - Cris Groenendaal Carlotta Giudicelli - Judy Kaye Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn Christine Daaé alternate - Patti Cohenour
	Sometime between July 1988 & October 1988. Crawford left in October	The Phantom - Michael Crawford Christine Daaé - Patti Cohenour Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman M. André - Cris Groenendaal Carlotta Giudicelli - Judy Kaye Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn Christine Daaé alternate - Dale Kristien (no images of this cast. There is a B&W insert of the current cast. This is an original brochure with Sarah Brighman, otherwise)
	June 1988	The Phantom - Timothy Nolen Christine Daaé - Patti Cohenour Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman M. André - Cris Groenendaal Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn Christine Daaé alternate - Dale Kristien (Photos, but NOT of this cast. They're of the Original B'Way Cast. Cast names do show up on the 3rd page of the brochure though. There must have been no time to update this brochure with photos since Nolen was the Phantom for a very short time.)
	Program from late 1988/early 1989. The actual brochure has the above cast listed within the program with a B&W insert of the following cast.	The Phantom - Cris Groenendaal Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe (B&W headshots, no images of current cast.. Looks like Groenendaal must have taken over not long after Nolen left. No images of Groenendaal, only of the original B'Way cast. This actual brochure, in the very front, lists Nolen as the Phantom. This is the brochure I bought at the theatre when I saw it my one and only time in New York.)
	June 1989	Generic Program. No cast listed, but it looks like Cris Groenendaal, and Rebecca Luker as the Phantom and Christine. There are some images of Steve Barton as Raoul, but not all of them look like him.
	Program produced in June 1989..but likely from sometime between March 1990-May 1990	The Phantom - Steve Barton Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Davis Gaines M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe (no images of current cast brochure says Groenendaal in it headshots for Barton. Barton took over in March 1990. David Romano (Piangi) left sometime between April/May 1990 so this brochure would have been from somewhere within those months.)
	November 1990	The Phantom - Kevin Gray Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe (No images of cast in brochure...one of the many generic ones. B&W images of this cast only.)
	March 1991	The Phantom - Mark Jacoby Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe (not pictured. There is a B&W insert who lists her as the alternate)
	July 1991	The Phantom - Mark Jacoby Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
	April 1992	The Phantom - Mark Jacoby Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
	June 1992	The Phantom - Mark Jacoby Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
	May 1993	The Phantom - Marcus Lovitt Christine Daaé - Mary D'Arcy Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro (not pictured--odd actually) M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout Meg Giry - Tener Brown Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
	November 1993	The Phantom - Marcus Lovitt Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes Meg Giry - Tener Brown Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
	July 1994	The Phantom - Davis Gaines Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes Meg Giry - Tener Brown
	February 1995	The Phantom - Davis Gaines Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Brad Little M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes Meg Giry - Tener Brown
	July 1995	The Phantom - Davis Gaines Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Brad Little M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes Meg Giry - Tener Brown Christine Daaé alternate - Laurie Gayle Stephenson Small insert with images of Laurie Gayle Stephenson as Christine Alternate and Elena Jeanne Bateman and Patrick Jones as Carlotta and Piangi
	January 1996 - 10th Year Anniversary	The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Hurd Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKeowan
	November 1996	The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine Meg Giry - Tener Brown Christine Daaé alternate - Teri Bibb
	August 1998	The Phantom - Davis Gaines Christine Daaé - Marie Danvers Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Lawrence Anderson M. Firmin - Chip Huddleston M. André - Ian Jon Bourg Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Hurd Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Jennifer Dawn Stillings Christine Daaé alternate - Susan Facer
	August 1998	The Phantom - Davis Gaines Christine Daaé - Marie Danvers Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Lawrence Anderson - Richard Todd Adams (Insert) M. Firmin - Chip Huddleston M. André - Ian Jon Bourg Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Hurd Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Jennifer Dawn Stillings Christine Daaé alternate - Susan Facer
	September 1998	The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Leigh Munro Madame Giry - Sally Williams Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso Christine Daaé alternate - Kimlee Bryant
	February 1999	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Leigh Munro Madame Giry - Sally Williams Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKewan (The beginning of the black brochures without tassles)
	June 1999 a	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
	June 1999 b	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Adrienne McEwan Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Joelle Gates Christine Daaé alternate - Sarah Pfisterer
	January 2000	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Sarah Pfisterer Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney Madame Giry - Leila Martin Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Joelle Gates Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKewan
	June 2001	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Jim Weitzer M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eighenberger Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Joelle Gates Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
	April 2002 - Autographed	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Lisa Vroman Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Michael Shawn Lewis M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eichenberger Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Joelle Gates Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
	December 2002	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Lisa Vroman Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eichenberger Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Joelle Gates Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
	October 2003 Msing color brochure, unfortunately	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Phillips Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Heather McFadden Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
	March 2004	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Phillips Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Heather McFadden Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
	December 2004	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews M. André - Jeff Keller Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Heather McFadden Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
	May 2005	The Phantom - Hugh Panaro Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Tim Martin Gleason M. Firmin - Jeff Keller M. André - George Lee Andrews Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Kara Klein Christine Daaé alternate - Rebecca Pitcher
	January 9th 2006- 7,486 performances. Breaking Cats' record	The Phantom - Howard McGillin Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Tim Martin Gleason M. Firmin - Tim Jerome M. André - George Lee Andrews Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt Meg Giry - Heather McFadden Christine Daaé alternate - Rebecca Pitcher (Much larger brochures. Resemble the UK brochures, now. Much classier than the older ones, IMHO)