Phantom of the Opera - Broadway

Based on my collection so far.
A list of the souvenir brochures

The goal of this section is to someday have photos of each brochure along with the cast lists. It'll never be complete, by any means but I sure can try.
Note: If there is a city, state and theatre listed, I either was at these performances, the name of the theatre was on the front of the brochure, or when I bought the brochure off ebay I had the info given to me by the seller.

The Majestic Theatre, Broadway, New York, NY

Images coming along with links Year Cast
Autographed by Michael Crawford, Sarah B, Steve B, and Judy Kaye
January 1988 - Autographed MC, Sarah B., Steve B., Judy Kaye The Phantom - Michael Crawford
Christine Daaé - Sarah Brightman
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Cris Groenendaal
Carlotta Giudicelli - Judy Kaye
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Patti Cohenour
Generic White Brochure Sometime between July 1988 & October 1988. Crawford left in October The Phantom - Michael Crawford
Christine Daaé - Patti Cohenour
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Cris Groenendaal
Carlotta Giudicelli - Judy Kaye
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Dale Kristien
(no images of this cast. There is a B&W insert of the current cast. This is an original brochure with Sarah Brighman, otherwise.)
Generic White Brochure June 1988 (?)
The Phantom - Timothy Nolen
Christine Daaé - Patti Cohenour
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Cris Groenendaal
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Dale Kristien
(Photos, but NOT of this cast. They're of the Original B'Way Cast. Cast names do show up on the 3rd page of the brochure though. There must have been no time to update this brochure with photos since Nolen was the Phantom for a very short time.)
Generic White Brochure Program from late 1988/early 1989. The actual brochure has the above cast listed within the program with a B&W insert of the following cast. The Phantom - Cris Groenendaal
Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Steve Barton
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
(B&W headshots, no images of current cast.. Looks like Groenendaal must have taken over not long after Nolen left. No images of Groenendaal, only of the original B'Way cast. This actual brochure, in the very front, lists Nolen as the Phantom. This is the brochure I bought at the theatre when I saw it my one and only time in New York.)
Generic White Brochure June 1989.
Tickets included in brochure. From March 7, 1990
The Phantom - Cris Groenendaal
Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Kevin Gray
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
(B&W headshots. No date included on it, but is numbered with the #9)
Generic White Brochure June 1989 Generic Program. No cast listed. In pictures it's, for the most part, Cris Groenendaal, and Rebecca Luker as the Phantom and Christine. Has an insert that shows every page and shows the actor/actress pictured. I've not seen any other brochure with this in it.
Generic White Brochure Program produced in June 1989..but show was likely from sometime between March 1990-May 1990 The Phantom - Steve Barton (Took over as Phantom March 19th)
Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Davis Gaines
M. Firmin - Nicholas Wyman
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - David Romano
Meg Giry - Elisa Heinsohn
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
(no images of current cast brochure says Groenendaal in it headshots for Barton. Barton took over in March 19th,1990. David Romano (Piangi) left sometime between April/May 1990 so this brochure would have been from somewhere within those months.)
Generic White Brochure November 1990
(Tickets included in brochure. Show was seen February 16, 1991. Alternates played the Phantom: Jeff Keller, M. André: Gary Baker, M. Reyer and Jeweler: James Romick)
The Phantom - Kevin Gray
Christine Daaé - Rebecca Luker
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine
Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
(No images of cast in brochure...one of the many generic ones. B&W images of this cast only.)
Generic White Brochure March 1991
(B&W insert published July 02, 1991. Also includes The Broadway Collection by Mail. Buy your POTO swag through the mail!)
The Phantom - Mark Jacoby
Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine
Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
(not pictured. There is a B&W insert who lists her as the alternate)
Generic White Brochure July 1991
(Note inside brochure shows the person went to see the show March 1992)
The Phantom - Mark Jacoby
Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout
Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey
Christine Daaé alternate - Katharine Buffaloe
Generic White Brochure April 1992 The Phantom - Mark Jacoby
Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout
Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey
Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
Generic White Brochure June 1992 The Phantom - Mark Jacoby
Christine Daaé - Karen Culliver
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Marilyn Caskey
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout
Meg Giry - Catherine Ulissey
Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
Generic White Brochure May 1993 The Phantom - Marcus Lovitt
Christine Daaé - Mary D'Arcy
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Hugh Panaro (not pictured--odd actually)
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Gary Rideout
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
Generic White Brochure November 1993 The Phantom - Marcus Lovitt
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Christine Daaé alternate - Luann Aronson
Generic White Brochure July 1994 The Phantom - Davis Gaines
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Generic White Brochure February 1995 The Phantom - Davis Gaines
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Brad Little
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Generic White Brochure July 1995 The Phantom - Davis Gaines
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Brad Little
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Christine Daaé alternate - Laurie Gayle Stephenson
Small insert with images of Laurie Gayle Stephenson as Christine Alternate and Elena Jeanne Bateman and Patrick Jones as Carlotta and Piangi
Generic White Brochure November 1996
B&W insert with date of October 1996. Only difference is Frederic Herringes played Ubaldo Piangi.
The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Christine Daaé alternate - Teri Bibb
Generic White Brochure November 1996
B&W insert with date of March 1997. Only difference is John Mac Master played Ubaldo Piangi. Also has a nice little pocket for extra inserts.
The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Elena Jeanne Batman
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine
Meg Giry - Tener Brown
Christine Daaé alternate - Teri Bibb
10th Anniversary Show January 1998 -
10th Year Anniversary
The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary
Christine Daaé - Tracy Shayne
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Hurd
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKeowan
Generic White Brochure March 1998.
The insert is ripped. The first page is missing, but the second page is there with date and rest of cast. B&W insert, but the date on it is January 1998. Not sure if it's a white cover or black cover.
The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Kelly  Ellenwood
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Frederic Heringes
Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso
Christine Daaé alternate - Kimilee Bryant
Generic Black Brochure September 1998 The Phantom - Thomas James O'Leary
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Leigh Munro
Madame Giry - Sally Williams
Ubaldo Piangi - Nicholas F. Saverine
Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso
Christine Daaé alternate - Kimlee Bryant
Generic Black Brochure February 1999 The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Cirán Sheehan
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Leigh Munro
Madame Giry - Sally Williams
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKewan
(The beginning of the black brochures without tassles)
Generic Black Brochure June 1999 a The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Geralyn Del Corso
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
Generic Black Brochure June 1999 b The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Adrienne McEwan
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Joelle Gates
Christine Daaé alternate - Sarah Pfisterer
Generic Black Brochure January 2000 The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Sarah Pfisterer
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Gary Mauer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney
Madame Giry - Leila Martin
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Joelle Gates
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McKewan
Generic Black Brochure June 2001 The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Jim Weitzer
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eighenberger
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Joelle Gates
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
Autographed by cast April 2002 - Autographed The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Lisa Vroman
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Michael Shawn Lewis
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eichenberger
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Joelle Gates
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
Generic Black Brochure December 2002 The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Lisa Vroman
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Rebecca Eichenberger
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Joelle Gates
Christine Daaé alternate - Adrienne McEwan
Generic Black Brochure October 2003 (x2)
Msing color brochure, unfortunately. One copy came with a playbill bought in December with inserts.
The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Phillips
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
Generic Black Brochure March 2004
The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Phillips
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
Generic Black Brochure December 2004 The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - John Cudia
M. Firmin - George Lee Andrews
M. André - Jeff Keller
Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Julie Hanson
Generic Black Brochure May 2005 The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Tim Martin Gleason
M. Firmin - Jeff Keller
M. André - George Lee Andrews
Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Kara Klein
Christine Daaé alternate - Rebecca Pitcher
New Brochure January 9th 2006- 7,486 performances. Breaking Cats' record The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Sandra Joseph
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Tim Martin Gleason
M. Firmin - Tim Jerome
M. André - George Lee Andrews
Carlotta Giudicelli - Anne Runolfsson
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Larry Wayne Morbitt
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Rebecca Pitcher
(Much larger brochures. Resemble the UK brochures, now. Much classier than the older ones, IMHO)
Record Breaking Brochure June 2007 The Phantom - Howard McGillin
Christine Daaé - Jennifer Hope Wills
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - (not pictured, but could be Michael Sean Lewis for this portion of the year)
M. Firmin - David Cryer
M. André - George Lee Andrews
Carlotta Giudicelli - Patricia Phillips
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey
Ubaldo Piangi - Roland Rusinek
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Susan Owen and Julie Hanson
Record Breaking Brochure 2008 The Phantom -
Christine Daaé -
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny -
M. Firmin -
M. André -
Carlotta Giudicelli -
Madame Giry -
Ubaldo Piangi -
Meg Giry -
Christine Daaé alternate -
Record Breaking Brochure 2009 The Phantom -
Christine Daaé -
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny -
M. Firmin -
M. André -
Carlotta Giudicelli -
Madame Giry -
Ubaldo Piangi -
Meg Giry -
Christine Daaé alternate -
Record Breaking Brochure 2010 The Phantom -
Christine Daaé -
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny -
M. Firmin -
M. André -
Carlotta Giudicelli -
Madame Giry -
Ubaldo Piangi -
Meg Giry -
Christine Daaé alternate -
Record Breaking Brochure Insert Date: March 2011
Brochure Date: June 2010
The Phantom - Hugh Panaro
Christine Daaé - Sarah Jean Ford
Raoul Vicomte de Chagny - Sean MacLaughlin
M. Firmin - David Cryer
M. André - George Lee Andrews
Carlotta Giudicelli - Liz McCartney
Madame Giry - Marilyn Caskey and Nancy Hess
Ubaldo Piangi - Evan Harrington
Meg Giry - Heather McFadden
Christine Daaé alternate - Marni Raab